Wilton's Most Trusted Realtors for 2026
Market Overview
Wilton's residential real estate market occupies a distinctive position within Fairfield County — more accessible than Westport or Greenwich, yet substantially above the Connecticut statewide median — with median listing prices around $1.34 million in early 2026. The town's defining characteristics shape every transaction: town-wide two-acre zoning, mature wooded lots, top-ranked public schools, and a 50-minute Metro-North commute to Grand Central. The buyer pool skews toward two-income commuter households, with meaningful inbound flow from New York City and Lower Fairfield County. Selling or buying successfully requires representation with deep local fluency and the brokerage network to navigate persistently thin inventory.
Key Market Statistics
Median Listing Price: $1,344,250
Median Days on Market: 29
Active Listings (Town-Wide): 19
New Listings per Month: 22
Total Licensed Wilton Agents: 191
Lot Size Standard: Two-acre minimum (town-wide zoning)
Primary Buyer Profile: Commuter households relocating from NYC or Lower Fairfield County
The rankings below draw on third-party performance data, including 36-month transaction volume in Wilton specifically, total career sales, brokerage credentials, years of experience, and verified client review counts
The Top 10 Realtors Serving Wilton, CT
1. Judy Michaelis — Coldwell Banker Realty
32 years of Connecticut real estate experience
Approximately $747M+ in all-time career sales
Average price point: $2.1M (highest on this list)
96+ verified five-star reviews across FastExpert, EffectiveAgents, and Zillow
Top 0.37% of agents serving the Westport / Weston / Wilton market
The most credentialed luxury veteran on this list. Michaelis brings more than three decades of hands-on transaction experience to Fairfield County's upper-tier market, with an average price point that nearly doubles the list median. Sellers in the $1.5M–$8M range will find her particularly well suited.
2. Max Dober — Keller Williams Prestige Properties
12 years of Fairfield County experience
175 verified client reviews
127 transactions over the last three years
6 closed Wilton transactions in the last three years
A high-output mid-market specialist. Dober's transaction volume is substantial for an agent in his career band, with consistent activity across Stamford, Norwalk, and Wilton. His review count is roughly 5x the list average, suggesting unusually high client-attention discipline. For buyers and sellers in the $500K–$1M range — Wilton's most competitive inventory band — his pricing instincts are well documented.
3. Susan Hanson — William Raveis Real Estate
24 years of regional experience
85 verified client reviews
William Raveis Real Estate — the largest family-owned brokerage in the Northeast
Average price point: ~$650K
A long-tenured Norwalk-based agent with deep regional roots. Hanson's career spans nearly two and a half decades — meaningful longevity in an industry where the average agent leaves within five years. William Raveis's regional dominance gives her access to coming-soon inventory smaller brokerages don't see.
4. Todd Auslander — Keller Williams Prestige Properties
25 years of experience
572 verified client reviews — the largest review base on this list
127 transactions in the last three years
7 closed Wilton transactions in the last three years
The most-reviewed agent serving the Wilton market. A review base of 572 reflects either a multi-year, multi-thousand-transaction career or a tight repeat-client operation — likely both. His Wilton transaction count places him in the top tier of Stamford-based agents who cross over into the Wilton submarket.
5. Kim Vartuli — Keller Williams
18 years of experience
169 verified client reviews
127 transactions over the last three years
6 closed Wilton transactions in the last three years
A Westport-anchored agent with strong Wilton crossover. Vartuli's review and transaction profile is comparable to the top producers on this list. Westport-based agents who consistently transact in Wilton bring their out-of-town buyer pipeline with them — meaningful in a market where many buyers come from outside Fairfield County.
6. Charles Nedder — Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices
23 years of experience; $681M+ in all-time career sales
191 verified client reviews
145+ transactions in the past 12 months
5 closed Wilton transactions in the last three years
A high-volume veteran with luxury-brokerage backing. Nedder's annual transaction count places him in the upper percentile of Connecticut producers, and his career sales figure rivals agents twice his tenure. BHHS brings concierge-level relocation services that align with Wilton's commuter-buyer profile.
7. Nicole J. Bates — NicoleJBates Team at William Raveis
24 years of experience
102 transactions in the last three years
Leads the NicoleJBates Team — a structured team operation rather than a solo practice
3 closed Wilton transactions in the last three years
A team-based operation with strong throughput. Bates leads a named team within William Raveis, providing coverage continuity that solo agents cannot match. With 102 transactions over the past three years, the team's combined output ranks among the most active in Lower Fairfield County.
8. Christine Oleynick — Keller Williams Prestige Properties
11 years of experience; ~$96M in all-time career sales
32+ verified client reviews
6 closed Wilton transactions in the last three years
Average price point: $1.2M
A rising mid-career producer aligned to Wilton's median price point. Oleynick's average transaction sits right at Wilton's median listing price, calibrating her marketing playbook to exactly the buyer Wilton sellers want to attract. Her percentile ranking reflects performance, not seniority.
9. Jessica Sigmund — Compass Connecticut
10 years of experience
102 verified client reviews
127 transactions in the last three years
2 closed Wilton transactions in the last three years
Greenwich-based, with the Compass marketing engine behind every listing. Sigmund's transaction count places her among the most active producers in her tenure band. The Compass platform — Concierge for pre-listing improvements, the private-exclusives network, and integrated CMA technology — supports every transaction.
10. Benjamin Howell — Coldwell Banker
13 years of experience
96 verified client reviews
9 closed Wilton transactions in the last three years — the highest Wilton-specific count among out-of-town agents on this list
77 total transactions over three years; average price point $1.1M
The most active Wilton-specific producer among out-of-town agents on this list. Nine closed Wilton transactions in three years is meaningful in a market this small — it represents recurring familiarity with Wilton inspectors, attorneys, septic services, and town hall, all of which matter at closing.
Choosing from the Top Real Estate Agents in Wilton, CT
The ten agents profiled above share the traits that separate strong representation from average representation in any market: a verifiable transaction history, a brokerage platform that adds value, and a client base willing to vouch for their work. In a market where the median home is worth more than $1.3 million and only 19 listings are active at any given time, the cost of choosing the wrong agent is measured in tens of thousands of dollars in lost equity for sellers and in missed inventory for buyers. The Wilton market in 2026 rewards preparation. Interview at least three agents from this list, ask hard questions about recent comparable transactions, and choose based on answers rather than chemistry.
